Skip to content

ALL PRODUCTS ARE ELIGIBLE TO MAKE AN OFFER!

Shop By Sport
Pokémon
Shop By Type
Shop By Player
- Young Guns
- Superstars
Shop By Price
All products

Baseball
Basketball
Football

Patch
Auto
Numbered Cards
Graded Cards

Young Guns
Superstars

Value Bin: $1 and below
Value Bin: Under $5
Value Bin: $5-$10

Account

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Superstars Cards

Skip to results list

Active filters:

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $1,500.00

Clear

Brand

CDP

Year

1990-99
2000-09
2010-2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
Vintage-1989

Brand

Bowman
Donruss
Optic
Panini
Prizm
Score
Select
Topps
Upper Deck

Sport

BASEBALL
Baseball
BASKETBALL
Basketball
FOOTBALL
Football
MULTISPORT

Graded

1

Set

1990 AAMER Sport (unlicensed)
2024-25 Bowman University Chrome
1997 Collector's Choice
1999 Pacific
2024 SkyBox Metal Universe Champions
2025 Stadium Club
2018 Topps Gypsy Queen
2026 Topps Heritage
Bowman
Donruss
Fleer
Hoops
MISC
Panini
Score
Skybox
Stadium Club
Topps
Upper Deck

Name

2023 MVPs (Shohei Ohtani / Ronald Acuña Jr.)
1st Series Check List 345-430 (Aaron Judge)
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge / Babe Ruth
AL HRs Leaders (Aaron Judge / Mike Trout / Yordan Alvarez)
Bo Jackson
Caitlin Clark
Cooper Flagg
Dominique Wilkins / Michael Jordan
Drake Maye
Elly De La Cruz
Fred Lynn / Shohei Ohtani
Home Run Leaders - 2023 (Shohei Ohtani / Matt Olson)
Kelly Oubre Jr.
Ken Griffey Jr.
Kon Knueppel
Michael Jordan
Mike Trout
Mike Trout / Shohei Ohtani / Anthony Rendon
Ohtani - Trout
Pals Face Off (Shohei Ohtani / Kohei Arihara) VC
Patrick Mahomes II
Patrick Mahomes II / Travis Kelce
Shohei Ohtani
Shohei Ohtani / Reid Detmers
Shohei Ohtani / Roki Sasaki
Shohei Ohtani / Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Tom Brady

Team

Charlotte Hornets
Chattanooga Lookouts
Chicago Bulls
Cincinnati Reds
Dallas Mavericks
Duke Blue Devils
Indiana Fever
Iowa Hawkeyes
Kansas City Chiefs
Los Angeles Angels
Los Angeles Dodgers
Los Angeles Raiders
New England Patriots
New York Yankees
North Carolina Tar Heels
Philadelphia 76ers
Seattle Mariners
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

587 items

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $1,500.00

Brand

CDP

Year

1990-99
2000-09
2010-2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
Vintage-1989

Brand

Bowman
Donruss
Optic
Panini
Prizm
Score
Select
Topps
Upper Deck

Sport

BASEBALL
Baseball
BASKETBALL
Basketball
FOOTBALL
Football
MULTISPORT

Graded

1

Set

1990 AAMER Sport (unlicensed)
2024-25 Bowman University Chrome
1997 Collector's Choice
1999 Pacific
2024 SkyBox Metal Universe Champions
2025 Stadium Club
2018 Topps Gypsy Queen
2026 Topps Heritage
Bowman
Donruss
Fleer
Hoops
MISC
Panini
Score
Skybox
Stadium Club
Topps
Upper Deck

Name

2023 MVPs (Shohei Ohtani / Ronald Acuña Jr.)
1st Series Check List 345-430 (Aaron Judge)
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge / Babe Ruth
AL HRs Leaders (Aaron Judge / Mike Trout / Yordan Alvarez)
Bo Jackson
Caitlin Clark
Cooper Flagg
Dominique Wilkins / Michael Jordan
Drake Maye
Elly De La Cruz
Fred Lynn / Shohei Ohtani
Home Run Leaders - 2023 (Shohei Ohtani / Matt Olson)
Kelly Oubre Jr.
Ken Griffey Jr.
Kon Knueppel
Michael Jordan
Mike Trout
Mike Trout / Shohei Ohtani / Anthony Rendon
Ohtani - Trout
Pals Face Off (Shohei Ohtani / Kohei Arihara) VC
Patrick Mahomes II
Patrick Mahomes II / Travis Kelce
Shohei Ohtani
Shohei Ohtani / Reid Detmers
Shohei Ohtani / Roki Sasaki
Shohei Ohtani / Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Tom Brady

Team

Charlotte Hornets
Chattanooga Lookouts
Chicago Bulls
Cincinnati Reds
Dallas Mavericks
Duke Blue Devils
Indiana Fever
Iowa Hawkeyes
Kansas City Chiefs
Los Angeles Angels
Los Angeles Dodgers
Los Angeles Raiders
New England Patriots
New York Yankees
North Carolina Tar Heels
Philadelphia 76ers
Seattle Mariners
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured

Most relevant

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

2019 Topps Chrome #100 Aaron Judge

2019 Topps Chrome #100 Aaron Judge

2019 Topps Chrome #100 Aaron Judge

$5.99

Sale price $5.99 Regular price
2018 Topps #OD-22 Aaron Judge MLB Opening Day

2018 Topps #OD-22 Aaron Judge MLB Opening Day

2018 Topps #OD-22 Aaron Judge MLB Opening Day

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
2018 Topps #TN-1 Aaron Judge Topps Now Top 10

2018 Topps #TN-1 Aaron Judge Topps Now Top 10

2018 Topps #TN-1 Aaron Judge Topps Now Top 10

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
2018 Topps Holiday #HMW99 Aaron Judge Metallic Snowflake

2018 Topps Holiday #HMW99 Aaron Judge Metallic Snowflake

2018 Topps Holiday #HMW99 Aaron Judge Metallic Snowflake

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge

2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge

2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
2020 Donruss #111b Aaron Judge : Batting Followthrough

2020 Donruss #111b Aaron Judge : Batting Followthrough

2020 Donruss #111b Aaron Judge : Batting Followthrough

$11.99

Sale price $11.99 Regular price
2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge Holo Purple

2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge Holo Purple

2020 Donruss #30 Aaron Judge Holo Purple

$11.99

Sale price $11.99 Regular price
2018 Topps Gallery #1 Aaron Judge Wood

2018 Topps Gallery #1 Aaron Judge Wood

2018 Topps Gallery #1 Aaron Judge Wood

$19.98

Sale price $19.98 Regular price
1993-94 Stadium Club #181 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Stadium Club #181 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Stadium Club #181 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1991-92 Hoops #30 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #30 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #30 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1991-92 Hoops #253 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #253 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #253 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1990-91 Hoops #65 Michael Jordan

1990-91 Hoops #65 Michael Jordan

1990-91 Hoops #65 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1991-92 Hoops #455 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #455 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #455 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1993-94 Upper Deck #171 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #171 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #171 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1989-90 Hoops #21 Michael Jordan

1989-90 Hoops #21 Michael Jordan

1989-90 Hoops #21 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1993-94 Upper Deck #237 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #237 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #237 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1993-94 Upper Deck #198 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #198 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #198 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1992-93 Topps #205 Michael Jordan

1992-93 Topps #205 Michael Jordan

1992-93 Topps #205 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1991-92 SkyBox #572 Michael Jordan

1991-92 SkyBox #572 Michael Jordan

1991-92 SkyBox #572 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1993-94 Stadium Club #169 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Stadium Club #169 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Stadium Club #169 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Hoops #536 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price
1993-94 Upper Deck #166 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #166 Michael Jordan

1993-94 Upper Deck #166 Michael Jordan

$9.99

Sale price $9.99 Regular price
1991-92 Fleer #220 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Fleer #220 Michael Jordan

1991-92 Fleer #220 Michael Jordan

$7.99

Sale price $7.99 Regular price

Join our email list

Get exclusive deals and early access to new products.

Email

© 2026 Varsity Collectibles, Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Refund policy
Terms of service
Contact information

Search

Search

Products

1994-95 Ultra #69 Hakeem Olajuwon

1994-95 Ultra #69 Hakeem Olajuwon

$1.25

Regular price Sale price $1.25
1994-95 Upper Deck #SE114 Grant Hill Special Edition

1994-95 Upper Deck #SE114 Grant Hill Special Edition

$1.34

Regular price Sale price $1.34
1995 Action Packed #14 John Elway

1995 Action Packed #14 John Elway

$1.34

Regular price Sale price $1.34
1995 Classic Images Four Sport #NNO Kerry Collins Draft Challenge Acetates

1995 Classic Images Four Sport #NNO Kerry Collins Draft Challenge Acetates

$1.99

Regular price Sale price $1.99

×

Please wait...

Make An Offer

We'll get back to you within 24 hours!

Descriptive image text

null

Name

Email

Quantity

Offer

Message

Descriptive image text

null

SKU: